For Mind, Reason, and Being-in-the-World: the McDowell/Dreyfus Debate, edited by Joseph Schear, Routledge Press, forthcoming.
From the Introduction:
Intellectualism is by definition a vice—the vice of overstating the role of intellect in experience and action, of seeing reason (or inferences, or concepts) where they are not. In what follows I find some justification for Dreyfus’ charge that McDowell’s views are intellectualist in this sense. But my reasons leave me room to agree with McDowell: our rational capacities also do, in a way, “pervasively shape” our experience, and this can make it misguided to look for some “core” of experience we share with sentient creatures that lack them.